Dining
Pine Island Dining:
- Lazy Flamingo 239-283-5959
- Reds Fresh Seafood Restaurant 239-283-4412
- Vesuvio Restaurant 239-283-0251
- Tarpon Lodge 239-283-2517
Upper Captiva Island Dining:
- Barnacle Phils~ casual dining beneath the outdoor Tiki hut or indoors amongst the room covered in dollar bills left by island visitors. (239) 472-6394
- Mango’s (239) 395-1500
- Over the Water Front~ Historic fish house, great food 283-2387
Off-Island Dining:
Captiva and Sanibel islands are well known for the wonderful variety of culinary experiences. If you don’t have your own boat, the fishing and taxi captain will transport you to these wonderful dining options. Some seasonal packages are available.Captiva Island
You may take your boat to your dock slip at McCarthy’s Marina on Captiva and walk to the Captiva restaurants listed below. Or, you may charter a captain to take you to Captiva Island.Dining options within walking distance of McCarthy’s Marina are:
- Sunshine Café - Casual fine dining for lunch and dinner. Reservations required by calling (239) 472-6200.
- Mucky Duck - Casual dining for lunch and dinner. Closed Sundays, call for reservations (239) 472-3434.
- Key-Lime Bistro - Open for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Dining indoors and outdoors. Live music. (239) 395-4000.
- RC Otters - Casual dining open for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Live music. (239) 395-1142.
- Bubble Room - Casual dining. This is a unique, outrageous restaurant (great for kids). They’re known for huge, delicious entrée portions and award-winning desserts. (239) 472-5558.
- Green Flash - Serving breakfast, lunch and dinner. (239) 472-3337.
Chamber's Website
Grocery Shopping
North Captiva Grocery Options
- The Island Market located near North Captiva Island Club provides “I forgot” type groceries only. A limited selection of wine is also available. Video rentals. We must encourage you to purchase groceries before taking the boat taxi to North Captiva.
- Curiosity Shop & Grocery Store above Barnacle Phils provides “I forgot” type groceries as well as clothing & gift items.
- Mainland Connection will deliver groceries to the house and placed in the refrigerator. For this service call (239) 283-6311. Their rate is 40% of the order, with a $50 minimum order.
Pine Island Grocery Stores:
- Anderson’s – Pine Island Road
- Public’s - At the intersection of Pine Island Rd. and Veterans Pk. They require 48 hours notice and will provide your order with a $10 fee. Please fax your order to (239) 282-5515.
- Winn Dixie – At the intersection of Pine Island Road and Longfellow at the Pine Island Crossroads
Captiva Island Grocery Stores
- Island Store provides “pick-me-up” type groceries only.
Sanibel Island Grocery Stores
- Jerry’s of Sanibel – At the intersection of Rabbit Road & Periwinkle Way. (239) 472-9300.
- Bailey’s – At the intersection of Tarpon Bay Road & Periwinkle Way. (239) 472-1516. Open daily 7:00A – 9:00P.
Island Shopping
North Captiva
- Coconut Connection – clothing, video rentals, accessories, and more!
- Curiosity Shop - above Barnacle Phils provides groceries as well as clothing & gift items
Captiva Island
- Chadwick Square – located near South Seas Plantation also has a variety of shops and dining options
- Andy Rosse Lane - the main street on Captiva has several shops and galleries
Sanibel Island
- Has a variety of boutiques and mini-malls located on Periwinkle Way. Please visit the Sanibel & Captiva Islands Chamber of Commerce website for additional options.
Ft. Myers
- The Bell Tower Shops – outdoor mall located on US 41 with a variety of well known stores and a great selection of dining options, movie theater, etc.(239) 489-1221